In essence, goods or
services transferred between two units of a company in
separate states would be taxed for IGST. While they
would be later refunded for this, it is expected to add
to their administrative complexities. Telecom companies
are expected to be one of the worst hit by the move. It
would be even more complex for a firm to transfer
services between two branches.
“This is a design feature which will be complex and will
have unforeseen consequences even if it doesn’t add to a
company’s tax liability,” said Satya Poddar, partner
Ernst and Young.
Similarly, the issue of taxation of services of an inter
state nature has also not been explained in the
discussion paper. There are a large number of services
like telecom, electricity and transmission which is
produced in one state and consumed in another state. The
discussion paper is silent on whether such services
would be taxed on an originating or end-use principle.
Sour